Best Eyebrow Pencils of 2025, Picked by 5 Leading AIs
We gave 5 top AIs—GPT-5, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and DeepSeek—one mission: rank the best eyebrow pencils after analyzing thousands of reviews and debating key features like precision and longevity. Their intense deliberation reveals a clear frontrunner.
No.1 AI-Picked Product
We had 5 AI models rank their top 5 products. We tallied the scores. Here's the winner with the highest score.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz was ranked #1 by 4 out of 5 AIs, achieving a near-perfect total score of 24/25 and an average rank of 1.2 across all models. It won for its ultra-fine 1.5mm tip enabling precise, hair-like strokes and rich pigmentation that lasts 12+ hours without smudging. The comprehensive 12-shade range with cool and warm undertones ensures versatile, natural results for all brow types.
What Each AI's Top Pick:
"Its ultra-fine, glide-on formula delivers crisp, high-pigment hair strokes with minimal pressure, and the truly waterproof wear stays put through long days and humidity. A broad, well-calibrated shade range with balanced undertones and a quality spoolie make it the most consistently top-rated by pros and users."
"Features an ultra-fine 0.003-inch tip for precise hair-like strokes with exceptional pigmentation and 12+ hour wear. Offers the most comprehensive shade range with 12 colors including cool and warm undertones, plus a built-in spoolie for seamless blending."
"This pencil is the industry gold standard, offering an unmatched balance of precise application with its ultra-fine tip and a perfectly waxy, pigmented formula. Its extensive color range and long-lasting, natural finish make it the top choice for both professionals and everyday users."
"This pencil tops the list due to its ultra-fine 1.5mm tip that allows for precise, hair-like strokes, offering excellent pigmentation and a wide range of 12 shades for various undertones. Its creamy formula ensures easy application without tugging, while the long-lasting, smudge-proof wear holds up all day, making it a professional favorite with a spoolie for blending."
"Ranked #1 for its ultra-precise application, rich pigmentation, and extensive shade range. The dual-ended design with a spoolie brush and long-wearing formula makes it a standout choice."
The AI Eyebrow pencils Leaderboard
See the total score and rank each product received from every AI model
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil
NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil
Fenty Beauty Brow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler
Rare Beauty Brow Harmony Precision Pencil
Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil
Huda Beauty #BOMBBROWS Microshade Brow Pencil
Kosas Brow Pop Nano
Dior Diorshow Brow Styler
Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
See Each AI's Full Top 5 Ranking
Here's exactly how each AI ranked the products. Click on each AI to see their complete, unedited reasoning.
GPT-5's Top 5 Rankings
Claude Sonnet 4's Top 5 Rankings
Gemini 2.5 Pro's Top 5 Rankings
Grok 4 Fast's Top 5 Rankings
DeepSeek V3's Top 5 Rankings
How We Calculated the Winner
Our 100% data-driven, transparent process
Ask Each AI for Their Top 5
We ask GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4, Gemini 2.5 Pro, Grok 4 Fast, and DeepSeek V3 to independently rank their top 5 products.
Apply Point System
Rank #1 = 5 points • #2 = 4 points • #3 = 3 points • #4 = 2 points • #5 = 1 point
Calculate Total Score
We add up the points from all 5 AIs. The product with the highest total score becomes our #1 AI-Picked Product.
You Decide
We show you the data. You make the choice based on your priorities and needs. This is a 100% data-driven process—we don't change the results.
Our Process
Independent Analysis
We ask ChatGPT-4, Claude 3.5, Gemini, and Perplexity the same question separately. No AI sees another's answer.
Full Transparency
You see everything: their reasoning, sources, pros, cons. We don't hide disagreements or cherry-pick answers.
You Decide
We present the data. You make the choice based on your priorities, budget, and needs. Because you're absolutely right.
Updated Monthly
Product markets change. We re-run AI debates monthly to keep recommendations current.
Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through Amazon Associate links. This helps us maintain this free service. Our AI debates are independent and unbiased—we don't influence what AIs recommend.